I felt kicked around by two outside-the-box projects this week. The famous one is You Can See Everything, the documentary I watched about convicted fraud artist Elizabeth Holmes, who was maybe, briefly, one of the richest women in the world through her medical company, Theranos. You’ve probably heard about it. Directors Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim filmed Liz Holmes and her partner Billy Evans in their home over the 34 days before Liz was due to report to prison. The filmmakers proposed the project. Astonishingly, Liz and Billy agreed.

This means Nathan Fielder spent part of the shoot literally embedded in the guest house of the pair’s seaside rental in California, although the bed they gave him had what looks like a plywood surface, no mattress. Billy told Nathan they liked sleeping that way themselves, even though the film shows them lounging on what appears to be an ordinarily comfy bed.

It’s hard to express the weirdness that transpires in this film. It isn’t your basic talking-heads documentary in which facts are set out in sonorous order. How Liz claimed to invent a revolutionary medical device that could diagnose multiple diseases by reading a small sample of blood. How she attracted mega-millions of dollars in investments with her claim. How the machine didn’t really work.

Instead, in diverse parts of the seaside rental, Nathan peppers Liz with off-the-wall questions about Theranos that she non-answers, her googly eyes unreadable. She denies any wrongdoing, goes even wider eyed when asked whether the device could in fact do what she said, or could possibly do it in the future, and at one point tells Nathan that she’s never lied in her life. Not once.

You can’t stop wondering whether she’s speaking some version of the truth; whether she’s in shock as she faces 11 years in prison; whether she’s genuinely clueless, maybe autistic, or if the film is her new con, a way to raise sympathy and start her rehabilitation—not to mention scare up investment for a new medical diagnostic machine she and Billy are developing.

And that’s only the first half of the film.

Meanwhile, I was reading a slim experimental book, Ivana Sajko’s 121-page novella, Every Time We Say Goodbye. It tells the story of a man riding a train from his home in Croatia toward Berlin after breaking up with his partner. 

Translated by Mimi Simić, the story is told in one sentence per chapter, each chapter/sentence around five pages long. It’s a run-on interior monologue that reveals, out of order, the narrator’s traumatic experiences as an abused child, as an unemployed journalist, as a witness to police brutality against migrants, and as the depressed partner of a translator who supports him financially while he lies in bed not writing a novel.

After spending a week with the doc and the novella, I’ve been asking myself questions about the latest forms of experimental art. I mean pieces in which nothing happens but everything does, just not in the order you expect. Has it become old-fashioned to look for your basic beginning, middle and end? To enjoy resolution and hope for even a small epiphany? Maybe the world is changing so radically that traditional forms of art can no longer capture modern life. 

Nathan Fielder

Our attention spans are famously shattered these days, to the point where publishers are deliberately bringing out shorter books.[1] I recently realized that my time spent scrolling had been going up and up and up, and set a strict time limit on using my phone. 

Yet my mind still butterflies around more than it used to, not least because I need to grapple with the fact that what was once consensus truth (vaccines work, genocide is bad) is now bitterly contested by bots, cranks and influencers, and sometimes by my friends. 

This leaves us living in a world coloured by dislocation and ambiguity, which seems to be part of what Ivana Sajko is trying to capture in her novella. It’s certainly what Fielder and Oppenheim are doing in You Can See Everything—and to brilliant effect.

The doc first.

Elizabeth Holmes, now 42, founded her first medical equipment business when she was not yet 20 and still a chemical engineering student at Stanford University. After reporting that she was raped on campus in 2003, Liz Holmes dropped out of Stanford and used her refunded tuition to amp her business into the famously fraudulent Theranos. The device Liz claimed to be developing was called Edison, a small metal box in which doctors could place as little as a pinprick of blood and receive a precise diagnosis of what was ailing their patients.

Her Stanford profs doubted this was possible. Nevertheless, Liz had raised $92 million in investment capital by 2010. Four years later, she’d pulled in more than $400 million from investors, among them Rupert Murdoch and Larry Ellison. Theranos was valued at $9 billion and Liz Holmes was very, very rich. 

At least for a few years.

Things started to unravel when Wall Street Journal reporter John Carreyrou received a tip that Edison was a fake, and that test results shown to doctors and investors were obtained by using other, established diagnostic devices. After months of research, Carreyrou published his bombshell story in 2015,[2] setting off a series of investigations and lawsuits. Eventually Liz and the former president of Theranos, Ramesh “Sunny” Balwani, were charged with fraud. 

Sunny Balwani had been Liz Holmes’s romantic partner during the golden days of Theranos. They’d met when she was 18 and still a student at Stanford. Sunny was 37 and married. They spent a decade together, but parted ways before going to trial. Liz said she’d fired him from Theranos, although Sunny said he’d quit. 

On the stand, Liz testified that Sunny had been controlling and sexually abusive, allegations that he categorically denied. She agreed, however, that Sunny hadn’t forced her to make false claims to investors. This was central to the prosecution’s case, since they argued that Liz had staged fake demonstrations of the device, falsified reports and made misleading claims about contracts, overstating the financial viability of Theranos. 

Both were convicted of multiple counts of wire fraud, and in 2022, Liz was sentenced to 11¼ years in prison. 

By then, she was in a relationship with Billy Evans, the heir to a small hotel chain, a self-described businessman eight years younger. Billy sometimes claims they’re married and sometimes says they aren’t. They had one child together before Liz was convicted, a son named William, born in 2021. She became pregnant again before her sentencing hearing, leading to allegations that she’d got pregnant to avoid starting her prison sentence, which Liz has denied. 

In any case, the judge allowed Liz to remain free until after the second child was born. Her daughter, Invicta, was a babe in arms when the film crew arrived. 

Why in God’s name did she and Billy let them in? Why, especially, did they let in Nathan Fielder, the on-camera face of the documentary team? Nathan is a comedian/performance artist/deadpan humourist who got his start in a Vancouver high-school comedy troupe with Seth Rogan. Maybe they had no idea who Nathan was? Because he’s Canadian? 

Billy Evans. Photo courtesy of CBS News

Or maybe the doc was filmed because Billy demanded a cut of any profit it might make, his ask coming before shoot began, surprising the film’s producers during a boardroom-style meeting at their dining room table. Liz had left the room shortly before, and it’s a matter of debate in the film whether she knew the terms Billy was about to table. Nathan and Lance Oppenheim nearly walked when the producers gave Billy his cut, but luckily they stayed, and we have this semi-decipherable, out-of-order masterpiece. 

It’s out of order in this case because Billy’s ask is only revealed late in the film, even though it happened before the official filming began. Maybe the directors felt it would undermine the credibility of the film if we learned too early that Billy owned part of it, although at least this key piece of information made it into the film.[3]

Liz Holmes’s background largely doesn’t. I harvested what I wrote earlier from many online sources (a shout-out to Wikipedia.[4] ) The audience doesn’t learn some key facts about Liz and Billy unless they scroll pre- or post-film—or during, which might explain why the annoying man beside me in the cinema kept consulting his phone, although maybe he was just checking his stock portfolio.

Yet in a funny way, the teasing lack of info (and the need to look it up afterwards) add to the power of the project, its pervasive sense of slippage and ambiguity. It makes the film a mystery, while our job is to play detective and figure out what’s really going on. And who doesn’t love a mystery?

We look back on Billy’s behaviour toward Liz somewhat differently, for instance, if we know she accused her former partner of being controlling. What’s really happening in the scene where she’s absent-mindedly beating eggs for an omelet and Billy grabs the bowl and beats them faster? Is he as controlling as Sunny was? (Or maybe wasn’t.)

It’s hard not to ask yourself whether Liz Holmes’s taste in men is part of what got her into this mess. Or does she permit men take over in small ways, appearing to control her, in order to keep her own hands clean? Is that why Liz left the boardroom-style meeting before Billy asked for a cut of the profits? Is she an abused woman or a manipulator? A genius, a victim, or maybe all (or none) of the above?

Billy’s character seems more readable, since the man lacks filters. He’s filmed taking a shower full-frontal, which the filmmakers later said he’d agreed to. In a recent interview Billy claims he didn’t give permission (or maybe he did) and that the lighting made his penis look black.[5] He’s the film’s bad guy, or maybe its foil—at least until Liz reports to prison on May 30, 2023, and he becomes the main character in the second half of the documentary.

Maybe that isn’t right, either. Maybe Nathan Fielder has become the protagonist, and grown every bit as unreliable as Liz. The expression you sometimes see on Nathan’s face when he looks at Liz suggests that he might be developing a crush on her. What’s all that about? And how does it affect what we’re learning, and maybe what’s left out of the film?

As the doc rolls on, it grows less authoritative rather than more so, until we reach a point where no one onscreen is fully reliable, nothing feels anchored, as we have no idea what’s coming next. 

Pretty much like life these days.

This is the point where most critics writing about You Can Say Everything stop saying anything. They don’t want to spoil the film’s big second-half surprise. Instead, they end their reviews by advising us to see it. Fade to black.

I’m not going to do that, since I’m not worried about ruining anyone’s viewing experience. There’s no way I can cover all the twists and turns in the film, which is almost three hours long, although it doesn’t feel like it. There will be plenty of surprises left after you read this—and, I hope, see the film.

Amanda Seyfried

So I’ll say that once Liz is locked away, Amanda Seyfried shows up: the actress who won an Emmy award for playing Liz Holmes in the 2022 Hulu mini-series, The Dropout. Amanda is here to play Liz Holmes in the documentary now that the real Liz is in prison. Nathan Fielder can visit Liz inside and they can talk on the phone, but he can’t record her voice or film her during their visits. If he tries, Liz will lose privileges, and maybe even be moved to a more restrictive prison in Arizona.  

So Amanda has arrived to recreate Liz’s conversations with Nathan, wearing prison clothes on a set that’s dressed like the visitor’s room at the Federal Prison Camp, Bryan, the minimum security facility in Texas where Liz is incarcerated. 

As Amanda says in a recent interview[6], she also wanted to spend time observing Billy Evans, having become curious about him after seeing some of the footage Nathan and Lance had shot. As it turns out, her on-camera interactions with Billy are hilarious. By this time, given the ambiguous nature of pretty much everything in the film, I wasn’t sure how much of the part Amanda played was off-the-cuff and how much was scripted. I also didn’t care. 

Some of it has to be extemporaneous. When Billy tells Amanda that he’s good in bed (direct quote: “I’m good in bed”), surely that’s his own unscripted line, and surely Amanda is speaking sincerely when she informs Billy that she’s told men they’re good in bed when they aren’t, a factoid that stuns Billy into silence. (He also tells her he likes Charlie Kirk.)

Then comes the most surreal scene in the film, and in any doc I’ve ever seen. 

Based on Nathan Fielder’s notes of their conversations, Amanda Seyfried plays Liz Holmes in prison expressing her extreme dislike of the way Amanda Seyfried played her, Liz, in the Hulu mini-series. This means Amanda, playing Liz, disses Amanda for playing Liz, and the audience in the cinema where I saw the film erupted in astonished howls of laughter.

Oh brave new world, to have such documentaries in it. 

Really, go see it. 

Then next week I’ll write about the unreliable narrator in Ivana Sajko’s novella, and spend more time thinking about the way in which we’re all trying to find our footing these over-the-top days, in life as well as in art. 


[1] Some publishers in Canada have asked that literary novels submitted for consideration top out at 90,000 words, and say they’re happy to read shorter submissions.

[2] In 2018, Knopf published Jon Carreyrou’s Bad Blood: Secrets and Lies in a Silicon Valley Start-Up. You can read about it here.

[3] According to a card at the end of the film, Billy later withdrew his claim for part of the film’s profits.

[4] Wikipedia is currently being challenged financially by peoples’ use of AI models, which of course have scraped its data. You can click on an any Wiki article and make a $2.50 donation to the site to help maintain its independence. 

[5] Billy recently gave an interview to CBS News, which you can access here.

[6] You can read Amanda Seyfried’s interview with Rolling Stone here.